December 14, 2011GR 172458; (December, 2011)Philippine National Bank vs. The Commissioner of Internal Revenue
December 14, 2011GR 178218; (December, 2011)Ramona Ramos, et al. vs. Philippine National Bank, et al.
December 14, 2011GR 185620; (December, 2011)Ruben C. Reyes vs. Tang Soat Ing (Joanna Tang) and Ando G. Sy
December 14, 2011GR 188376; (December, 2011)Land Bank of the Philippines vs. Federico Suntay, as represented by his assignee Josefina Lubrica
December 14, 2011GR 188381; (December, 2011)Baguio Trinity Developers, Inc., herein represented by Ricardo Julian vs. The Heirs of Jose Ramos, et al.